Two losing trades before 10:00 is an ordinary morning. A setup failed, a stop got hit, and both losses were the size you planned. What turns that morning into the worst day of the month is usually what comes next: the bigger size to win it back, the entry without a stop, the chase into a move that has already run.
Traders call this tilt. Most think they know whether they do it, but a journal can answer the question with your own trades. Below is how to look for it, and how to test a simple stop rule against your history before you commit to it. The examples assume US stock and ETF day trading.
Three signs of tilt in your trades
Tilt rarely shows in a monthly P&L. It shows in the order of trades inside a day. Look for:
- Worse results after a losing streak. Do the trades you take after two straight losses lose more often than the rest?
- Bigger size after a loss. Compare the shares or dollar risk on the trade after a loss with your average.
- Bigger losers late in red days. If the late losers are larger than the early ones, a stop was probably moved, widened or never set.
Mistake tags make this quick. If you tag trades chased, oversized or no stop when they break your plan, you can filter to exactly those trades and see when in the day they happen.
One day, two ways
Take this made-up day:
- 9:41, trade 1: -$200
- 9:58, trade 2: -$180
- 10:12, trade 3: -$350, at double size
- 10:40, trade 4: +$120
- 11:05, trade 5: -$420, with no stop
- 11:30, trade 6: +$90
The day ends at -$940. The two planned trades lost $380; the four that followed lost another $560. Stopping after the second straight loss would have ended the day at -$380.
A single day settles nothing, though. On some other day trade three might have been the winner that saved the morning. The only fair test is your whole history.
Testing a stop rule on your history
The method:
- Use a period long enough to mean something, three months or more.
- Go through each day in order. When the rule fires (a second straight loss, a daily loss limit, a cut-off time), drop every trade opened after it for the rest of that day.
- Compare the actual equity curve with the one under the rule: net P&L, trade count, profit factor and the deepest drawdown.
A spreadsheet can do it, but pairing fills into trades and walking every day by hand is slow. SpiceLog‘s What if report runs the test for you. Turn on a rule (stop after a number of straight losses, stop at a daily loss, no new entries after a set time, skip certain tags or tickers) and it draws your actual equity curve beside the one with the rule. A stop drops every trade opened from the moment it fired to the end of that New York trading day, and the drawdown is followed trade by trade, so a dip inside a day still counts when the day closed green.
Read the result with care
The test only removes trades you actually took. It can’t know what you would have done instead, so treat it as hindsight, not a forecast. Before you adopt a rule:
- See what it removed. If it cut some of your best winners along with the tilt trades, it’s too tight.
- Count how often it fired. A rule that fired twice in six months has little to say.
- Weigh the drawdown, not just the total. A rule that leaves P&L about the same but halves your deepest dip can still be worth having.
- Try nearby settings. If two losses helps and three doesn’t, look at what the third trade of those days did.
If a rule holds up, put it in your written plan as a hard limit, set it in your broker platform if it has a daily loss limit, and check it in your weekly review. For picking a dollar figure, see our guide to setting a daily loss limit.
The short version
Two losses is normal. What you do after them decides the day. Your trades already hold the answer, so check them before the next red morning does it for you.
SpiceLog is free, imports DAS Trader Pro and other broker exports, and includes the What if report. Try it on sample trades, no sign-up needed.
For education only, not investment advice.
Leave a Reply